The Residence of Orson Samuel Gorton in North Brookfield, N. Y.


Today, I don't have a portrait of a person to share with you, but a magnificent-looking house to identify. According to the handwritten information on the back, this was the residence of O. S. Gorton in North Brookfield, N.Y., in April 1903.

I'm no expert in architecture, so I'm relying on AI for a little help here. The house looks like a substantial 19th-century home, possibly built in the Italianate style that was so popular among well-to-do American families at the time. I particularly like the little tower-like structure on the roof, the decorative details along the roofline and the covered front porch. The taller central part, with the lower sections on either side, gives the house quite an elegant and imposing appearance. I wonder what it must have been like to live there!
But now to the owner - who was O. S. Gorton? What do the initials stand for? The census records, along with a public family tree on Ancestry, came in very handy in identifying the owner of this residence as Mr. Orson Samuel Gorton.
Orson Samuel Gorton was born on October 19, 1835, in Brookfield, Madison County, New York, the eldest son of Samuel Orson and Sarah, née Camp. His younger brother, Oscar M. Gorton, was born two years later. Sadly, tragedy struck the young family when their father Samuel died in 1839, leaving Orson fatherless at just four years old. His mother Sarah remarried, and the boys grew up with their stepfather, Deloss A. Worden, and five half-siblings in North Brookfield.
In 1855, Orson was 19 and worked as a blacksmith, just like his stepfather.
In January 1858, Orson married Sarah I. Warren, who was from Connecticut. By 1865, the couple were living either next door to his parents or in the same household. By then, Orson had switched trades and was working as a wagon maker, an occupation listed for him in every census through 1880.
Census records are very helpful when gathering the basic facts about someone's life. But they can be rather modest in what they reveal, especially when it comes to this particular family, as I was about to discover!
The Gorton family was actually among the earliest settlers of Brookfield. According to the History of Madison County, Captain Samuel Gorton (1745–1834) arrived in Brookfield in 1795, selected two lots of land and then returned to his native Greenwich, Rhode Island. The following spring, his sons Varnum and Benjamin travelled there on foot to prepare for the rest of the family. They cleared the land and built a cabin about three miles east of North Brookfield, on what became known as Gorton Hill. The remainder of the family arrived in the autumn, consisting of Samuel and his wife, together with ten more children.
The 1899 county history specifically explains that Gorton Lake, a small lake in the northern part of Brookfield, was named after the Gorton family of settlers. It also identifies Gorton Hill as the location of the original homestead.

Going even further back in history, Orson's fifth great-grandfather was Samuel Gorton (1592–1677). He emigrated from England to New England in search of religious freedom. His unorthodox beliefs brought him into conflict with the Puritan authorities. He later founded Warwick, Rhode Island, and served as President of the mainland settlements of Providence and Warwick from 1651 to 1652.
But back to Orson's life!
Orson, his brother Oscar and their respective wives lived close to one another in 1870. Both brothers are listed as wagon makers in the 1870 Census, and apparently their businesses were successful, as both had accumulated considerable wealth. According to the census, Orson declared a total of $9,000 in real estate and personal estate in 1870, equivalent to approximately $230,000 today.
Once again, however, the census records are far too modest to tell us the whole story. In fact, North Brookfield was a village particularly famous for its wagon and carriage manufacturing. North Brookfield wagons and carriages were sold throughout Madison, Oneida, Otsego and Chenango counties, giving amoung others the name Gorton a wide reputation.
In other words, the Gorton family was not merely involved in wagon making as individual craftsmen. Orson Gorton actually ran a successful wagon manufacturing business, employing craftsmen who worked under him for 25 years.
Orson was also a man of innovation. According to a blog post about him, he secured “at least two patents on improvements in wagon springs and wagon gears. One newspaper called them, "one of the greatest improvements on wagons that has been made in the 19th century.”
The 1868 Madison County directory also lists Orson as a Justice of the Peace, in addition to his manufacturing business producing carriages and lumber wagons.

By the 1880 Census, the brothers were still living close to one another, but both were now listed as farmers. And by the time Orson was in his sixties, the 1900 Census had him down as a gardener.
Once again, that is a rather modest interpretation of the truth!
According to his obituary, published in The Courier of Brookfield on August 22, 1923, Orson had large holdings in oil wells in Pennsylvania and after selling out there, he went to Florida and purchased a tract of land and set out an orange grove, which he later sold.
Hence – "gardener"!
As for Orson's brother Oscar Gorton, who was listed as a farmer in the 1900 Census, he had also moved on from wagon making to hop farming. The emerging automobile industry was reducing the demand for horse-drawn wagons. According to this blog, Oscar grew hops to be used in the making of beer as the area was known for this industry, and it seemed that Oscar thrived as a farmer.
It looks as though neither Sarah and Orson nor Oscar and his wife Helen had children. But I know for a fact that family, and keeping in touch with his Gorton relatives, was important to Orson. With such a rich family history, I'm not surprised that I came across this delightful clipping in the Daily Sentinel of August 1, 1890, reporting on the 7th Gorton family reunion, presided over by Orson Gorton himself. At the reunion, he was elected President of the Gorton family executive committee.

Sadly, Orson was widowed in May 1903.
Orson stayed active in the community and in November of the same year, he was elected co-director of the Brookfield Cemetery Association:
In 1906, at the age of 71, Orson married Mary Ann Morris, a schoolteacher. Mary Ann was more than 20 years younger than Orson and had never been married. The couple spent their final years together, with Orson's brother Oscar and his wife Helen living close by.
Orson's obituary praises Mary Ann for her warmth and devotion to her husband during his later years, when palsy (paralysis) gradually took over his body and left him bedridden.
Orson passed away in August 1923 and was buried at North Brookfield Cemetery.
Here is the full text of his obituary, as published on the blog At the Riverbend, written by Dianne:
"Orson S. Gorton. August 16th, Orson S. Gorton passed on to a higher life. He was a lifelong resident of North Brookfield and was born near the village October 19, 1835, on what is called 'The Gorton Lake Farm.' He was of pioneer ancestry, the great-grandson of Captain Samuel Gorton of the fifth generation who settled on a hill a little above Gorton Lake, in 1795, and built a log cabin where the old homestead now stands. Capt. Gorton was a descendant of Samuel Gorton, an associate of Roger Williams in the foundation and government of historic Rhode Island Colony. Orson Samuel Gorton was the son of Samuel and Sarah Camp Gorton. He was a wagon and carriage manufacturer in earlier years, and was identified with other enterprises. He had large holdings in oil wells in Pennsylvania and after selling out there, he went to Florida and purchased a tract of land and set out an orange grove, which he later sold. In 1877, he united with the Baptist Church at North Brookfield, and previous to this, he was chorister and organist for 30 years. He was one of the trustees of the church the same length of time. He was a faithful and loyal member, keeping the appointment of the church whenever he could. His political preferment was for the Republican party. He served several years as one of the inspectors of the election and several times was justice of the peace. A great lover of birds, Mr. Gorton had a cabinet of mounted birds, collected from all parts of the state, with many rare specimens from the Southland, especially from Florida. Connoisseiurs have pronounced his collection second to none in the state. Mr. Gorton was twice married, his first wife, Sarah Isabell Warren of East Hartford, Connecticut, died May 10, 1903. Later he married Miss Mary Morris of Cassville, who serving and who has won praise and admiration of everyone for her faithful and untiring care of him. His illness resembled palsy, which gradually wore him out. For the past three years, he had been confined to the bed, requiring constant care. He was a successful businessman and a good citizen, having the respect and confidence of all whom he came in contact. Besides his wife, he leaves one brother, Oscar M. Gorton, also a half sister, Mrs. Alida Burhyte of N. Brookfield. Funeral services were held from the home Sunday afternoon, Rev. Seeley York, pastor of the Baptist church, conducting the services. Mr. York, who has been closely associated with the deceased, gave a very comforting address. Mrs. G. A. Hardy of Utica rendered most exquisitely two solos, 'My Father's Land' and 'The House of the Soul.' Many beautiful floral pieces, besides the home flowers from the neighbors' gardens, were tokens that went to show the high esteem in which the deceased was held. A large gathering of relatives and friends was present from Utica, this place and the surrounding villages. C. W. Burhyte, C. W. Talcott, F. E. Hibbard, and C. K. Mason acted as pall bearers."
And what became of this magnificent house? I have no idea whether it is still standing, and despite my attempts, I haven't been able to establish its exact location. I'm not even sure whether it is the same house, but I did find a residence marked as belonging to O. S. Gorton on an 1875 map of North Brookfield, kept at the New York Public Library Digital Collection (I've marked the house with a pentagon).

Interestingly, it was just a couple of houses away from the Warden household, where his mother and stepfather lived.
I've contacted the North Brookfield Historical Society in the hope that someone might recognise the house or shed some light on its history. Perhaps it is still there, quietly standing somewhere in North Brookfield. I would love to find out!









Kommentare